The playbook
// 02 of 08 · 6 min read

You get 5 seconds. Use them.

A stranger decides whether to keep scrolling before they read a single paragraph. Here is how we make the first screen do the selling.

// How we think

Paid traffic does not fix a broken storefront. It exposes one.

The people your ads reach are curious, not committed.

Curious leaves at the first sign of confusion.

So the first screen has one job: answer three questions before they think to ask them.

// Why it matters

It's bigger than one page.

Ad efficiency

Your real cost per customer is your ad cost divided by your conversion rate. A first screen that loses people quietly doubles what every customer costs you.

Brand equity

The first screen is your shelf. If a stranger cannot tell what you are and why you are different, you look like every other brand in the category.

Retail

Buyers watch how you sell online. A store that converts cold traffic is proof the brand can move without a retailer doing the work.

// The framework

The 5 second test

  1. 01
    What is this, and who is it for?

    Product name, what it does and who it is for, in plain words. "Hydration, reimagined" does not count.

  2. 02
    Why should I trust it?

    Reviews, a real customer quote or a number, close to the title. Not buried at the bottom of the page.

  3. 03
    Why would I want it?

    The benefits that matter, as short scannable lines or icons. What it does for them, not what is in it.

// What good looks like
1.4%
Average Shopify conversion rate
3.2%
Top 20% of stores
4.7%
Top 10% of stores
53%
Leave a page that takes over 3 seconds to load

Food and beverage stores convert around 2.6 to 3%. For repeat-purchase CPG, we aim for 3% or more.

// What winning brands do

Checked on their live sites, October 2026.

// Our results
Dumo
Eat Blake's
+58%
revenue per visitor
+41%
conversion rate

A full copy, positioning and offer overhaul. Both numbers in 30 days, on 21% less traffic.

See the product page
Savannah Bee
+24.4%
conversion rate

in 30 days, during a historically slower sales period

Motiv Matcha
A homepage that sells

Within seconds you know what it is, what it does for you and where to buy it.

See their store
Catalina Crunch
Benefits before the scroll

Our partner. A big-name brand whose product page says what it is, what it does for you and why to trust it before the first scroll.

See the product page
// Do this week

Start here.

From the toolkit
// CPG Brands on Shopify

Let's Talk
Strategy

Get in touch with us. Our CRO experts will talk through your strategy, your goals and where you want to go, and how we'd get you there.

Book a strategy call
Charlie Dumo in a DUMO jacket at Shopify