Most CPG brands lose money on the first order. That is fine, as long as you know when the customer pays you back. Plug in your numbers and see.
For the last 12 months, give me: my average order value, my gross margin after product cost, shipping and payment fees, and the average number of orders per customer.
Paste it into Sidekick in your Shopify admin and it pulls the numbers below.
Fill in your numbers and your answer shows up here. Don't know them? Copy the Sidekick prompt and it pulls them from your store.
Getting a customer costs money. On most CPG orders, the margin on order one does not cover it.
That is normal. The question is how many orders it takes to earn it back, and how fast those orders come.
Under 6 months is healthy for DTC. Under 3 is best in class.
Past 12 months, you are financing growth, not earning it. Every new customer makes the hole deeper before it pays off.
Every reorder from a customer you already have comes with no ad cost. That is why the habit is the whole business model in CPG.
A subscriber reorders on a schedule, so the payback clock runs on its own. Set orders per year to 12 and watch what happens to your answer.
Bigger first orders: pack sizes, bundles and a free shipping threshold raise what each new customer spends on day one.
A faster second order: subscribe and save, post-purchase emails and a reminder right before they run out bring them back sooner.
Get in touch with us. Our CRO experts will talk through your strategy, your goals and where you want to go, and how we'd get you there.
Book a strategy call