The playbook
// 04 of 08 · 7 min read

AOV is designed, not discovered.

Average order value is not something that happens to a brand. It is something the brand builds into the page.

// How we think

Most founders treat AOV as an output. It is an input.

A restaurant does not leave the average check to chance. Neither should you.

The most expensive thing you can do is sell a new customer a single unit.

Give every pack size a job, and make the smart choice the easy one.

// Why it matters

It's bigger than one page.

First-order profit

At a $32 AOV and a $28 cost per customer, you lose money on order one. At $58, the first order breaks even and every repeat is margin.

Habit

One unit runs out before the habit forms. A bigger first order means they use it long enough to need it.

Price integrity

Bigger orders through packs and bundles protect your price. Discounts train customers to wait for the next sale.

// The framework

The four levers we pull

  1. 01
    Make the multi-pack the obvious choice

    Preselect the size most customers should buy, and show the price per serving on every size.

  2. 02
    Give every size a job

    Try it, Most Popular, Best Value. Labels do the thinking so shoppers do not have to.

  3. 03
    Set a free shipping threshold just above your AOV

    If your AOV is $42, set it around $48 to $55, and show a live bar: "You’re $8 from free shipping."

  4. 04
    Make the cart drawer sell

    It's your highest-intent moment. Show the free shipping bar, a one-tap upgrade to subscribe and save, add-ons they can drop in without leaving, and the savings they're getting.

// What good looks like
~$63
Average food and beverage order
~$29
What paid ads spend to win one food and beverage order
58%
Of shoppers add items to qualify for free shipping
// What winning brands do

Checked on their live sites, October 2026.

// Our results
Dumo
Pistakio
$38 → $46
average order value

with an in-cart add-on

See their store
A viral olive oil brand
$28 → $45
average order value

from pack tiers and a subscription default, in 90 days

Craven Cups
A bundle builder that feels like a game

Shoppers build their own box. It raises the order size, lets them customize, and makes shopping feel like a game.

See it live
Ribbonwire Ranch
Pack sizes plus a bundle upsell

Clear pack sizes and a bundle upsell right on the product page.

See the product page
// Do this week

Start here.

From the toolkit
// CPG Brands on Shopify

Let's Talk
Strategy

Get in touch with us. Our CRO experts will talk through your strategy, your goals and where you want to go, and how we'd get you there.

Book a strategy call
Charlie Dumo in a DUMO jacket at Shopify